| Platinum | Caffe Luciano's |
| Gold | Idaho Pizza Company |
| Silver | Brick 29 |
| Bronze | The Griddle |
| Top Pick | Corona Village |
| Top Pick | Eagle Rib Shack |
| Top Pick | Garibaldis Garden City |
| Top Pick | Luciano's Italian Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Twin Peaks Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Uncle Giuseppe's |